Manager Evaluation Survey | 50+ Must Ask Questions

Trusted by 5000+ Brands

Top Secrets to a Powerful Manager Evaluation Survey

Manager Evaluation survey is more than a checkbox exercise. It's your ticket to honest feedback and clear data on leadership performance. When you run a quick poll or full survey, you signal that you value your team's voice. Tools like our Management Evaluation Survey template can speed up your setup.

Start with clear goals. The Rutgers guide on Developing a Survey Instrument stresses concise questions and bias reduction. Define what you want to learn - leadership clarity, recognition habits, growth support. Then match each survey question to a clear objective.

According to Wikipedia's Performance appraisal entry, tying evaluation to clear objectives boosts buy-in across cultures. In a recent project, a sales team used a survey to spot weak spots in communication. They asked "How clearly does your manager communicate expectations?" and spotted gaps in weekly check-ins. Armed with real data, they revamped meeting agendas and saw double-digit increases in close rates.

Sample prompts: "How often does your manager recognize team achievements?" and "Do you feel your manager supports your professional growth?" can open rich conversations. At the end, you'll gain a clear roadmap for coaching, peer benchmarks, and unbiased feedback. Pair your survey with follow-up chats to turn data into action. That's the secret sauce.

Remember to keep responses anonymous to encourage honesty. Schedule check-ins quarterly to track progress and not overwhelm your team. Ready to launch? Customize your questions, pilot with a small group, then roll out. Your leadership team will thank you for the insights.

Illustration depicting the concept of unlocking the power of Manager Evaluation survey questions.

Illustration highlighting high-impact topics in Manager Evaluation survey questions.

5 Must-Know Mistakes to Dodge in Your Manager Evaluation Survey

Too often, teams skip clear objectives in a Manager Evaluation survey. Mixing leadership, culture, and process in one survey muddies your insights. Define your main goal - communication, recognition, or growth - and stick to it. That focus keeps results relevant.

Another common mistake lies in survey intros. Without context, employees may doubt confidentiality. A brief note explaining how you'll use feedback builds trust. It also increases your response rate, as shown by SurveyMonkey.

Leading questions erode reliability. Phrases like "Don't you agree…" push respondents toward positive answers. Use neutral phrasing instead, as the NARISH Intl. blog suggests. If you catch bias, rework your wording before you launch.

When a tech startup skipped anonymity, feedback skewed toward praise. Employees filtered criticism, and real issues went unnoticed. After switching to anonymous submissions, they uncovered gaps in mentoring schedules and built targeted training.

Use clear prompts such as "What could your manager do to support you better?" and "How well does your manager resolve team conflicts?" Those open-ended items often reveal rich insights. Pair those questions with a Manager Feedback Survey tool to compare results across teams.

Finally, pilot your survey with a small group and refine based on feedback. Keep surveys short - 10 to 15 questions max - to respect your team's time. Correct these mistakes and you'll launch with confidence.

Communication Skills Questions

Strong communication lays the foundation for effective management and team cohesion. These questions help identify how well your manager conveys information, listens to feedback, and fosters an open dialogue through a Manager Effectiveness Survey .

How clearly does your manager explain tasks and objectives?
Clarity in messaging minimizes confusion and ensures team members understand their responsibilities, leading to better performance.
How effectively does your manager listen to your concerns and suggestions?
Active listening builds trust and indicates that your feedback is valued, which can enhance engagement and collaboration.
How frequently does your manager provide updates on project status?
Regular updates keep the team aligned on progress and help identify potential roadblocks before they escalate.
How approachable is your manager when you need clarification?
Approachability encourages team members to seek guidance early, reducing errors and promoting a supportive environment.
How well does your manager adapt communication style to different team members?
Tailoring communication ensures that diverse personalities and work styles receive the information they need in a way they understand.
How effectively does your manager handle difficult or sensitive conversations?
Managing challenging discussions with tact preserves morale and ensures issues are addressed rather than ignored.
How clear are the written instructions your manager provides?
Clear written guidance serves as a reliable reference and reduces the likelihood of misinterpretation in complex tasks.
How responsive is your manager to emails and messages?
Prompt responses demonstrate respect for your time and maintain momentum on projects.
How well does your manager summarize team meetings and action items?
Summaries reinforce key takeaways and ensure everyone knows their follow-up responsibilities.
How confident are you in your manager's verbal presentations?
Effective presentations reflect managerial credibility and help sell ideas to stakeholders both inside and outside the team.

Leadership & Vision Questions

Assessing a manager's leadership and vision is crucial to understand their ability to inspire and guide the team toward long-term goals. These questions explore the clarity of vision, strategic alignment, and motivational leadership through a Leadership Evaluation Survey .

How clearly does your manager articulate the team's long-term goals?
Clear goals ensure everyone understands the desired outcomes and can align their efforts accordingly, reducing confusion and increasing motivation.
How effectively does your manager connect daily tasks to the bigger picture?
Linking routine work to larger objectives enhances engagement by showing the impact of individual contributions.
How well does your manager inspire and motivate the team during challenges?
Strong motivational skills help maintain morale and productivity when obstacles arise, fostering resilience.
How proactive is your manager in identifying future opportunities and risks?
Anticipating changes ensures the team can prepare in advance, reducing disruptions and leveraging new possibilities.
How consistently does your manager model the organization's core values?
Leading by example demonstrates commitment to company culture and encourages the team to uphold shared standards.
How adaptable is your manager to industry trends and shifts?
Flexibility in leadership helps the team stay current and competitive in a rapidly evolving market.
How well does your manager encourage innovation and creative thinking?
Supporting new ideas fosters a culture of continuous improvement and can lead to breakthrough solutions.
How effectively does your manager align team efforts with company strategy?
Strategic alignment ensures resources are focused on key initiatives that drive organizational success.
How often does your manager communicate a clear vision for upcoming projects?
Frequent vision updates maintain focus and enthusiasm, ensuring the team stays on track toward objectives.
How confident are you in your manager's ability to lead through uncertainty?
Confidence in leadership during unpredictable times is essential for maintaining stability and guiding the team forward.

Team Management Questions

Effective team management is the cornerstone of a high-performing group, balancing delegation, support, and conflict resolution. Use these questions to evaluate how your manager cultivates teamwork, assigns tasks, and maintains team morale via an Employee Management Survey .

How effectively does your manager delegate tasks based on individual strengths?
Matching tasks to skills improves efficiency and satisfaction, leading to higher-quality work and professional growth.
How fairly does your manager distribute workload among team members?
Equitable workload distribution prevents burnout and ensures resources are utilized optimally across the team.
How well does your manager recognize and celebrate team achievements?
Public recognition boosts morale and reinforces positive behaviors, contributing to a supportive team culture.
How effectively does your manager address conflicts within the team?
Timely conflict resolution keeps relationships strong and prevents small issues from escalating into larger problems.
How supportive is your manager when team members request help?
Providing support demonstrates managerial commitment to collective success and encourages collaboration.
How openly does your manager solicit input from the team on decisions?
Inclusive decision-making fosters ownership and can lead to more innovative and accepted solutions.
How well does your manager set clear performance expectations for the team?
Clear expectations align efforts and provide measurable criteria for success, guiding performance and growth.
How effectively does your manager monitor team progress and adjust as needed?
Adaptive oversight ensures the team stays on track and can pivot quickly when priorities shift.
How confident are you in your manager's ability to build a cohesive team?
Team cohesion drives collaboration and trust, which are essential for achieving complex objectives.
How well does your manager foster a culture of respect and inclusivity?
An inclusive environment promotes diverse perspectives and ensures all team members feel valued.

Performance Feedback Questions

Regular, constructive feedback is vital for employee growth and alignment with organizational goals. These questions assess how your manager delivers performance reviews, offers constructive criticism, and follows up via a Manager Feedback Survey .

How regularly does your manager hold one-on-one performance discussions?
Frequent check-ins provide timely feedback, ensuring employees can adjust behaviors before patterns become entrenched.
How constructively does your manager deliver criticism?
Constructive criticism focuses on behaviors and outcomes, guiding improvement without damaging morale.
How balanced is the feedback between positive reinforcement and areas for improvement?
Balanced feedback motivates employees by acknowledging strengths while clearly addressing development needs.
How actionable are the performance improvement suggestions provided?
Clear, actionable guidance enables employees to implement changes effectively and see measurable progress.
How well does your manager set and review performance goals?
Jointly set goals align expectations and empower employees to take ownership of their development journey.
How timely is the follow-up after performance evaluations?
Prompt follow-up ensures that agreed-upon actions are implemented before momentum is lost.
How transparent is your manager about performance metrics and criteria?
Transparency builds trust and helps employees understand exactly how their performance is assessed.
How effectively does your manager tailor feedback to individual learning styles?
Personalized feedback resonates better and supports targeted growth based on how each employee learns best.
How supportive is your manager in helping you achieve development milestones?
Support through resources and encouragement is crucial for turning feedback into tangible skill improvements.
How confident are you that your manager follows up on agreed development plans?
Follow-up commitment demonstrates accountability and reinforces the importance of continuous development.

Decision Making Questions

Decision-making skills determine how managers navigate challenges and allocate resources effectively. These questions examine your manager's analytical approach, risk assessment, and decisiveness with a Performance Management Survey .

How thoroughly does your manager gather information before making decisions?
Comprehensive data collection reduces the risk of oversights and supports well-informed choices.
How effectively does your manager involve relevant stakeholders in the decision process?
Stakeholder input ensures diverse perspectives are considered, increasing buy-in and solution quality.
How adept is your manager at weighing potential risks and benefits?
Balanced risk assessment helps prevent unintended consequences while capturing opportunities.
How confidently does your manager make timely decisions under pressure?
Decisiveness in high-pressure situations keeps projects moving and prevents delays from indecision.
How often does your manager revisit and adjust decisions based on new information?
Adaptive decision-making shows flexibility and a commitment to continuous improvement as conditions change.
How transparent is your manager about the rationale behind decisions?
Sharing the reasoning builds trust and helps the team understand the larger strategy guiding choices.
How willing is your manager to take calculated risks for innovation?
Embracing calculated risks can lead to breakthroughs but still requires careful planning to mitigate downsides.
How consistently does your manager follow through on decisions made?
Reliability in executing decisions maintains credibility and reinforces organizational stability.
How well does your manager learn from past decision outcomes?
Reflecting on and applying lessons from past choices fosters growth and reduces repeat mistakes.
How confident are you in your manager's ethical judgment during decision-making?
Ethical considerations ensure decisions align with company values and legal requirements, maintaining integrity.

Professional Development Questions

Supporting professional growth is a key managerial responsibility that drives employee satisfaction and retention. These questions evaluate how your manager coaches, mentors, and provides development opportunities through a 360 Feedback Survey .

How often does your manager discuss your career aspirations?
Regular career conversations align employee goals with organizational needs, fostering mutual growth.
How effectively does your manager provide mentorship or coaching?
Personalized mentorship accelerates skill development and builds long-term capabilities within the team.
How supportive is your manager in identifying relevant training opportunities?
Proactive training recommendations help employees stay current and advance in their roles.
How well does your manager help you set achievable development goals?
Clear goals provide direction and measurable outcomes for tracking professional progress.
How frequently does your manager review your progress on development plans?
Regular reviews ensure momentum is maintained and barriers to growth are addressed promptly.
How accessible is your manager for career-related guidance?
Easy access to guidance demonstrates commitment and encourages open dialogue about growth.
How effectively does your manager recognize and leverage your strengths?
Strengths-based development maximizes employee potential and improves job satisfaction.
How supportive is your manager when you pursue stretch assignments?
Backing stretch assignments shows confidence in abilities and fosters skill diversification.
How well does your manager facilitate networking or cross-team collaboration for you?
Networking opportunities broaden experiences and can lead to innovative solutions through cross-pollination of ideas.
How confident are you in your manager's investment in your long-term growth?
Investment in development signals to employees that they are valued, boosting loyalty and engagement.

FAQ

What are the key areas to focus on when creating a Manager Evaluation survey?

A Manager Evaluation survey template should cover leadership, communication, conflict resolution, decision-making, team collaboration, and professional development. Use example questions tailored to each area, clear rating scales, and open-ended prompts. A balanced mix of quantitative ratings and qualitative feedback yields actionable insights for managers and guides continuous improvement.

How can I effectively assess a manager's communication skills in a survey?

Combine Likert-scale items measuring clarity, responsiveness, and active listening with scenario-based example questions. Include open-ended prompts on email, meeting, and presentation skills. This survey template approach offers quantitative scores and qualitative feedback, ensuring a comprehensive assessment of a manager's communication skills and actionable recommendations.

What questions should I include to evaluate a manager's leadership and vision?

Include example questions on vision articulation, goal alignment, and team motivation. Use Likert scales to rate goal-setting clarity, delegation effectiveness, and strategic decision-making. Open-ended prompts invite feedback on inspiration and empowerment. A well-structured survey template combining quantitative and qualitative items provides a comprehensive leadership and vision evaluation.

How do I measure a manager's ability to handle conflicts within the team through a survey?

Use scenario-based example questions to rate mediation skills, fairness, and resolution effectiveness. Include Likert-scale items on handling disagreements, fostering compromise, and maintaining team cohesion. Open-ended prompts gather detailed feedback on conflict intervention. A targeted survey template with conflict management questions yields quantitative scores and qualitative insights for improvement.

What are the best practices for designing a 360° Manager Evaluation survey?

Best practices include using a survey template with multi-source feedback - self, peer, direct report, supervisor - and ensuring anonymity. Balance Likert scales with open-ended example questions. Provide clear instructions, communicate purpose, and pilot-test your free survey format. A structured 360° Manager Evaluation survey yields comprehensive insights and equitable feedback.

How can I assess a manager's support for employee professional development in a survey?

Include example questions on mentoring frequency, training access, goal alignment, and skill coaching. Use Likert scales to rate supportiveness and open-ended prompts for program suggestions. A survey template focusing on professional development yields quantitative data and qualitative input, helping HR identify strengths, gaps, and targeted growth opportunities.

What survey questions can help evaluate a manager's decision-making and problem-solving skills?

Include scenario-based example questions to rate analytical thinking, timeliness, and stakeholder consultation. Use Likert scales for identifying issues, selecting solutions, and evaluating outcomes. Add open-ended prompts for decision-making rationale and learning reflections. A specialized survey template delivers quantitative metrics and qualitative feedback, enabling a clear view of problem-solving skills.

How do I gauge a manager's effectiveness in fostering team collaboration through a survey?

Ask example questions on meeting facilitation, cross-team projects, feedback sharing, and inclusive decision-making. Use Likert scales to rate participation levels, communication clarity, and alignment on shared goals. Open-ended prompts collect collaboration stories and improvement ideas. A collaboration-focused survey template provides quantitative scores and qualitative insights into team dynamics.

What are effective ways to measure a manager's adaptability and change management skills in a survey?

Include example questions on change communication, agility, and resilience. Use Likert scales to rate planning, stakeholder engagement, and responsiveness to shifting priorities. Add scenario-based prompts about recent transitions and open-ended items for lessons learned. A change-management survey template captures quantitative adaptability scores and qualitative insights into leadership flexibility.

How can I ensure anonymity and honesty in Manager Evaluation survey responses?

Host your free survey template on a secure, anonymous platform. Clearly state confidentiality and avoid collecting personal identifiers. Use unique, unlinkable access codes or email invitations. Provide data usage transparency and reminders about privacy. Emphasizing how candid feedback supports manager growth boosts honesty and yields more reliable evaluation results.

Question		Response
What is your relationship to the manager being evaluated?		Other
How long have you worked with this manager?		Less than 6 months
The manager communicates effectively.		4
The manager demonstrates strong leadership and decision-making.		3
The manager provides clear goals and expectations.		1
The manager supports my professional development.		2
The manager applies policies fairly and consistently.		3
The manager fosters a positive and collaborative team environment.		2
What does the manager do well? Please provide specific examples.		This is a test
What areas could the manager improve?		This is a test
I am satisfied with the feedback and recognition I receive from the manager.		2

Unlock and Upgrade

Remove all limits from your Polls

Free Manager Evaluation Survey

50+ Expert Crafted Manager Evaluation Survey Questions